Banning the negative talk in children
What was your childhood like in your school?
Were your teachers nice?
Do you remember the ones who used to yell at the class or have a positive attitude?
As i’ve been sitting here this morning making my classes work I got to thinking about a lesson that I taught last week that was sort of an A-HA! moment for me.
It had nothing to do with the effect that chemicals had on our plants for our science investigation..
Or the work on the working wall…
It had to do with the personality traits and characteristics of a character in a science fiction story that we were reading. Keill was a young boy who wanted to be a legionnaire on his home planet. He was only 12 years old and he had to get through a challenge within two days. This challenge showed how brave, strong, patient, determined and loyal he was. I had to explain to the children what the word characteristic meant and how they could apply that word to themselves. I asked a few of them if they could start to describe themselves, just like we did for Keill.
They sat there for a few minutes, looking at me like what the heck are we supposed to say? Finally I gave them an example.
Ok I said…I think Sanjida is a very hard worker. That is a characteristic that describes her.
Some faces started to light up. Others just sat looking at me blankly.
I asked them again to come up with some ways to describe themselves. Some hands went up.
Funny, thoughtful, pretty, tall…
All of a sudden after a few positive things I started to get some negative responses.
…naughty, loud, disorganized.
I was confused at this point because I didn’t expect the children to come out with negative ways of describing themselves. Then I decided to ban the negative. I told them that they were no longer allowed to use negative words, but had to focus on the positive.
After a few minutes, I didn’t get many hands up and then I finally asked how many of you find it difficult to come up with a positive way of describing yourself?
Two thirds of the class hands went up. I was pretty shocked! The reason for this was they were either too embarrassed to say something positive about themselves, OR they really has no idea how to compliment themselves and think positively.
When I asked why this was a boy put his hand up and said that he always remembers the negative things people say to him, like his parents, teachers and friends. Surely, he has had positive things said to him – but when you are told negative things as well- you often remember them more clearer in your head.
It was an A-HA! moment for me because it made me think about the way I talk to children. It made me realize that I must STRESS the positive to them, and although children need to be told when they have done something negative they must be given a chance to learn from it and then be rewarded for the positive thing that they do afterwards to correct it.
Children are like little sponges.. they take in everything you say and believe it. You tell them they are naughty and they will believe they are naughty. You tell them how disorganized they are and they may grow up thinking they will always be disorganized.
I’m planning on trying to focus more on the positive in my classroom…
…and i’m really trying to use positive reinforcements for the children so that they don’t believe they are full of negatives. Even if their handwriting isn’t the greatest or they continue to spell the same word wrong, giving them support and showing them how to do it and being a positive motivator is the key thing here.
Remember my plan of attack?? This definitely falls in to it.


I was literally JUST talking about this the other day with one of my coworkers. On Wednesday I had seven parent conferences. Six of them went SO well…and one pissed me off. I left the day thinking to myself UGH I hate conferences, parents are so annoying etc. No…not parents, just that ONE set of parents that day…most of them were great!
I also agree it’s much harder to say good things about yourself. I am much better at it now that I am older, but I wish we could teach kids to be good at it. They are NATURALLY good at it, because MOST can do it still in kindergarten…it’s when they get a little older it becomes harder I think.
I wish you’d been one of my teachers growing up!! Well, that would’ve been creepy because I’m older than you, but you know what I mean. I went to a school where many of the teachers catered to the children of school board members, right or wrong. I’d get bullied, then get in trouble for it because the bullies were the kids of, you guessed it, school board members. There wasn’t that much of a nurturing environment…i love your idea!
You sound like such an amazing teacher. Wow. And what insightful children- it is so true that the negative comments stick like glue.
You are making such a difference in these kids lives- they will always remember you.
I love this post! In school, I was always scared of my teacher. I never wanted to say or do the wrong thing — I hard spoke in class. I hated when the teacher pointed out my mistakes and not my successes. The world needs more teachers like you.
That’s awful that the one kid remembers negative things more. Actually, in my developmental psych seminar at school we were discussing autobiographical memories & why people tend to remember negative events better, and it’s usually because those negative things are not consistent with how we think of ourselves so they stand out a lot more in your memory. I find that’s true in my own life – some of those negative moments really stick with you and it’s so unfortunate! Good for you to focus on the positive things. I think that’s so important, especially when you’re in an authority type position as a teacher, as kids really look up to that. I think having a positive, encouraging teacher will make such a difference for those kids
This is such a powerful idea, Leah. I love that you turned it around and limited it only to positive.
I don’t necessarily remember one way or the other about my teachers encouraging positivity, but my dad is a HUGE believer in positive thinking, so I grew up a lot with that.
You are such a great teacher! Those kids are lucky to have you.
Awww this post made me tear up!!!! What a wonderful message to give to them. It is so sad the world children have to grow up in today…
I was also wondering if you had that a-ha moment for YOURSELF? As in, did you start to realize that you describe yourself in a negative way too? I think it can apply to adults and kids alike!
You sound like an amazing teacher. What a beautiful message!! I wish I had teachers like you growing up.
i LOVE this post!! i’m also a canadian teaching in england (east london) and i’ve been struggling with how teachers here focus on the negative ALL the time. i work in a wonderful school with an awesome staff but very rarely do i hear a child being praised for something positive. it’s heartbreaking. so i’ve been working VERY hard at praising the heck out of my kids! i’m in a year one class so it’s easy to find things to gush over, even just the little things like making a big deal out of when they say “please” makes their faces light up. and they’ve really been responding to it. one little girl was just horrible at the beginning of the year, acting out, looking for attention any way she could (inevitably finding only negative attention because the only way she could get attention was by being bad), and just being an all-around pain. so i starting ignoring the bad and praising the good and what a difference!! she still has her tough days but for the most part she is a totally different kid, so sweet and funny! awesome what a new attitude can achieve
I love children <3
Leah, as a teacher, I almost think that this is the most helpful thing you can do
Childhood is exactly where the seeds of negative self-talk start and your idea to block/change that is fantastic!
I am so happy that people like you become teachers. You will have such a positive impact on these children at a time when their minds are growing. School can be very difficult for some kids, and I know it was a challenge for my brothers and I who are all very creative but don’t always work well with set rules. I struggled with many subjects but had a few teachers that were so helpful and so encouraging that I pulled through strongly with their help. Keep up the good work, you are making more of a difference than you will ever know!
Leah – this is such a big issue with kids!
In my old classroom, we played a game called Give, Get, or Go. Each student got a chance to be it. They could choose one of the three G’s. if they picked Give, they could give anyone in the room a compliment. If they picked Get, up to five people could give them compliments. If they picked Go, they could pass.
After the first couple of times we did it, NO one picks go. It is a fun way to get people talking and trying to be creative to come up with new words to use as compliments (nice, funny, and cool were vetoed).
Keep on being positive! Show them you love them every day. Sometimes, we are the most influential adult in thier lives. Remembering that is sobering, but it really helps me to let go of my own drama before I go into that classroom, when I think about that fact.
I completely agree with trying to focus on the positive, but are things like loud, and disorganized really negative ways of describing yourself? Some people are disorganized, but it works for them. I would be careful with how you choose to define negative. Obviously, naughty, bad, stupid, ugly are negative, but some things that perhaps you see as a negative characteristic aren’t really meant that way?
I think this is such a wonderful post – I’ve kept it marked as unread in my reader for awhile now just so I can keep coming back to it. It’s so important to remember to focus on the positive things – and as adults we so frequently are at fault for focusing on the negatives, but kids… kids learn from what others tell them… You’re so wonderful for making an active effort to reward kids for their positive behaviors. Thank you for being a shining light